Book or Cook? The Booking of Titus O’Neil

Titus O'Neil

Craig Wilson & Brian Damage

The WWE roster is filled with “superstars” at every level. There are the main roster guys who regularly appear on Raw and SmackDown, those who are used as glorified jobbers and those who are barely used at all. In this series of pieces, we will take an individual wrestler barely used and decide if they are worth keeping or should they be let go. Today we decide if we Book or Cook Titus O’Neil.

Craig: I think Titus was always a contender for ‘Book or Cook’, even before his somewhat bizarre suspension.

Unreleated to his current plight, I’ve always felt sorry for Titus. I mean, just as the Prime Time Players were getting some momentum the legs were cut from under them and they were split up without even proper feud between them to show for it. Then with nothing for either to do, they were thrown back together.

Don’t get me wrong, they have a connection with the crowd in a way that will make a lot on the roster jealous but they do little or nothing for me. I get that he’s impressively built but beyond that, I find him a bit blah.

Is there any hope for Titus? Is this suspension the beginning of the end for him?

Brian: Titus O’Neil seems to be (at least from what I’ve read and seen) a quality human being. He is a Dad of the year, extremely charitable and puts on a great face for the company. He is a very likable person outside the ring. As for the Titus inside the ring…I agree…he is very bland and not all by his own fault. I think Titus has good comedic timing and charisma…it just doesn’t translate well in the ring as of yet.

Something just isn’t clicking and I don’t know what is missing. As far as his 60 day day suspension (Reduced from 90 days) I have to believe there is more to that story than what’s already been reported.

Craig: It is worth considering that the WWE could still turn this around, remove suspension and turn it into an angle. Capitalise on media interest and sympathy for Titus and push forward with him.

Can anyone see him as a solo, or even a tag, star? Or is his mid card pairing with Darren Young as likely as far as he’ll go? I get that not everyone can, or needs to be a main eventer, I hasten to add.

Brian: I was thinking the exact same thing. The WWE can easily turn this into an angle and help Titus get “over” but seeing the company’s track record with missed opportunities…..this might be another one of those. I don’t think Titus is main event material, but then again, who knows? Was he ever really given a shot at the brass ring?

Like Cesaro before him, McMahon tends to label people almost immediately. It took a large outcry from fans to push Cesaro and Daniel Bryan. I just don’t see that with Titus…but with the mainstream news covering the story…you never know.

Craig: that’s an interesting point. Be curious to see what backlash, if any, there will be from fans towards the company. If there’s none then it shows his standing with the fans and that the so-called ‘brass ring’ will be one that he won’t ever grasp.

It’s clear that there’s something with Titus. He undoubtedly has the look and his charity work will cut him some slack. It will certainly be interesting to see how he does when he returns from his suspension. If he returns and is booked strongly then there is every chance that Titus O’Neil could be a big star.

There’s also still time that the WWE could book this whole thing as an angle and use it to move on with Titus. Only time will tell with him but there is undoubtedly something there with Titus. Whether or not he makes it as a big star is another thing…

You can read all previous ‘Book or Cook?’ pieces here.

7 thoughts on “Book or Cook? The Booking of Titus O’Neil

  1. I’d say book him to become someone as a thorn in the side of the League of Losers and actually one-up them and become a solid mid-carder. He’s got the potential as Shane’s return to the WWE is now giving me hope that things will change and maybe watch WWE again.


  2. I think O’Neill has loads of potential, but it seems like he isn’t gonna get that big Daniel Bryan-type break, especially after what just recently happened. Cook him, in WWE, but book em if he’s TNA or GFW-bound. He’s a world-class athlete and a decent guy. This should not be the preemminent thing that we remember him for. In TNA, he’d be a world title contender easily. But Vince isn’t ever gonna let him out of that doghouse, at least not completely. So if I’m him, I would leave Bizzaroland a,d move on to greener pastures. NJPW would also be a good place for him, Can you imagine him as a member of the Bullet Club? I can, very easily.


  3. Book book book all the way. When he comes back he’s already got an inbuilt feud and the fans would be solidly behind him because who the hell DIDN’T think this was totally unwarranted. WWE could really do something with this and make him white hot. With Ryback looking like he’s turning heel you could have him backing up The Authority feuding with Titus with his vendetta against the Authority. I really hope they don’t drop the ball with him but I have a feeling they might.


    • That would be great, Timelord, but remember, this is the WWE; do you really think this would actually happen? WWE has consistently dropped the ball on stellar performers like O’Neill, Darren Young, Nataylia, and Damien Sandow. All of these performers should have visible, clearly defined roles in WWE, instead of becoming cannon fodder and having a huge joke made out of their careers. Vinnie Mac ain’t gonnas let Titus get over that hill now. No way.


  4. Pingback: This Week in Wrestling 2016 week 9 | Ring the Damn Bell

  5. Pingback: Book or Cook? The Booking of Wade Barrett | Ring the Damn Bell

  6. Pingback: Book or Cook? The Booking of Darren Young | Ring the Damn Bell

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.